I’ve written recently about “deep models” used to explain the experiences we as therapists have in the clinic, and it’s only fair that I offer my own. By deep model I mean the description of those processes occurring beyond our vision or sensation that ultimately account for what we observe empirically. Deep models are essential if we are to understand both the failure and success of technique, and they should not violate physical law, as we currently understand it.
Stretch Activated Ion Channels: How Touch Translates To Sensation
The translation of mechanical deformation in various tissues to an electrical signal strong enough to be sensed and properly interpreted by the brain has been explained several different ways.
Sensation of any sort requires a difference in net charge across the neuronal membrane that exceeds its normal resting potential. Achieving this state normally requires the influx of sodium or calcium through "ion channels": cylinder-shaped protein molecules that permit chemical diffusion to occur without energy expenditure. When enough channels open, depolarization occurs and the experience of sensation is then possible.
It has been known that ion channels may be ligand (chemical) or voltage (electrical) gated. Recently, ion channels that are activated via increased membrane tension have been discovered in many tissues. Mechanically sensitive tissues throughout the body possess stretch-activated (SA) ion channels capable of immediately responding to deformation of the tubes, rods, and strings that form the matrix of the cytoskeleton. These channels account for the propagation of sensation secondary to movement (proprioception) or internal stress (interoception).
Altering the SA ion channels in various sequences will eventually produce
voltage gated ion propagation, which is very much like lighting a fuse, sending
a quick message to the brain via the inter-neurons. The resting membrane
tension of the cytoskeleton is directly related to the ease with which
mechanical deformation may recruit enough SA ion channels necessary to
eventually promote nervous depolarization. The higher the resting tension,
the easier it is to open a sufficient number of channels.
If the resting tension in the epithelium and its intimately associated connective tissue is higher than normal, a chain reaction of channel opening will be facilitated. This is ultimately displayed by a report of sensation that knows no neurologic boundary. The absence of a typical dermatological reference is due to the fact that numerous tissues unrelated to nervous tissue possess SA channels. They may serve as a bridge from one dermatome to the next mediated by mechanical deformation of the connective tissue between nerves.
If distant sensation and change are common with Simple Contact, it’s reasonable to assume or propose the following:
The absence of distant sensation with
provocative contact is due to the inevitable muscle guarding elicited with
that type of handling. This effectively sets up a barrier that will not
allow the domino-like effect necessary for sensation to spread.
Distant sensation and change are more likely to occur in areas of symptomatology due to the facilitated state of the local nervous tissue.
Changes in sensation distantly can commonly be accounted for by an alteration in autonomic flow, identifying this nervous system as intimately and persistently involved in chronic discomfort.
The effect of the technique arises from the recruitment of SA ion channels. Naturally, these are most easily stimulated in tautly bound tissue, more likely to be symptomatic. Perhaps all cranial technique is essentially dependent upon the effective recruitment of SA ion channels and the various hand placement and movements elicited are really just a way of searching for the most effective entryway into the system. This would account for the tremendous variety of response to technique from patient to patient as well as the inability to match symptoms and techniques.
Understanding the potential effect of Simple
Contact in this way allows the therapist to appreciate how sensation and
change in our patients can occur with remarkable variety and speed.
Relinquishing the agenda usually present with manual care and choosing to be a
companion to the patient and their unique processes reveals the intelligence and
corrective power every person possess. This attitude arises from an
understanding of the materials we handle, and if we deform the skin without a
distinct knowledge of what happens next, and why, the potential for distant and
profound change is lost.
The Intimate Sense; Understanding the Mechanics of Touch by Frederick Sachs. "The Sciences" Jan/Feb., 1988 Published by The New York Academy of Sciences, Two East Sixty-Third Street, New York, NY 10021
Baroreceptor Mechanisms at the Cellular Level Frederick Sachs; 1986 Update In Cardiovascular Neurobiology; Federation Proceedings Vol. 46 No. 2 January 1987
Mechanotransducer Ion Channels in Chick Skeletal Muscle: The Effects of Extracellular PH Guharay and Sacks Journal of Physiology (1985) 363 pp. 119-134.
Single-Channel Currents from Acetylcholine Receptors in Embryonic Chick Muscle Averback and Sachs, Biophysics Journal Vol. 45, Jan.l984
Stretch-Activated Single Ion Channel Currents in Tissue-Cultured Embryonic Chick Skeletal Muscle Guharay and Sachs Journal of Physiology (1984) 352 pp. 685-701
The Canvas Tent Metaphor
A scientific explorer of the world has to decide when to reduce an issue
to its material constituents and when to remain metaphorical.
Joel Achenbach in Captured by Aliens
The deep model above, in my experience, is insufficient when it comes to describing the consequences of touching the skin of another. Actually, you don’t actually have to touch the skin itself; deforming it through just about any clothing will work just as well.
Imagine you’re in a canvas tent in the rain. An experienced camper will know better than to touch the sides of the tent. This would orchestrate an opening in the fibers of the cloth large enough to allow leakage. The opening created is far too small to see, but it’s there nonetheless. If I didn’t understand anything about canvas, that is, if I didn’t have a deep model, this leaking would remain mysterious to me.
When we touch the skin, it leaks. The exchange of ions through the stretch-activated channels is enhanced by the membranous tension already present. More tension makes it easier to elicit reflexive reaction to touch. This makes scars, facilitated segments and areas of increased muscle tone better “doorways” into the nervous system.
You might notice that there is no way according to this model to elicit sensation without actually deforming the skin. Waving your hands near to the surface isn’t going to do anything other than what might be accomplished through some form of psychological appeal. The deep model used to explain that is well beyond the scope of my expertise.